Retirement is one of the most significant transitions most adults will ever face. It’s as momentous, researchers say, as becoming a parent, getting married or divorced, or leaving home for the first time.
If you’re retired and having emotional difficulties dealing with this transition, that’s normal.
Unfortunately, in our culture, we only highlight the pluses of retirement, and no one warns you about the negatives of the transition you’ll be facing. When you’re having difficulties, you almost feel guilty admitting that that’s the case. Isn’t retirement supposed to be 24/7 wonderful?
In this post, I want to help you place where you are in the transition process and suggest practical ways to move from the negatives to the positives.
Where You Might Be Right Now
Dr. Riley Moines identified four phases that most retirees go through:
Phase 1 is the vacation. It feels like a permanent vacation: freedom, no alarm clocks, no deadlines, no boss! This usually lasts about a year, and it’s great for at least a while until it starts to feel boring and you wonder if this is all life is.
In Phase 2, retirees feel loss and lost. The six losses hit hard: the loss of identity, purpose, meaning, status, social connection, and structure. No one warned you about these, and they catch you off guard.
Many people get stuck here and try to fill the void with back-to-back cruises, busyness, and distraction, which doesn’t work.
This is the phase where depression is most common and most unacknowledged. Some self-medicate with drugs and alcohol, and some take the extreme step of suicide in order to escape the feeling of loss and lost.
In Phase 3, you move from the feeling of loss into the exploration and experimentation phase. It’s a time to try new things to find out what works and what doesn’t.
In Phase 4, you reinvent yourself. During exploration and experimentation, you find new meaning, purpose, and identity. In Phase 4, retirement starts to feel like an identity rather than an absence of one. You might describe yourself as a writer, a mentor, a volunteer, or a traveler. Something real, not just ‘retired.’ The restlessness of Phase 2 is gone. You’re not filling time anymore; you’re living it.
The Path from Lost to Reinvented
Let’s look at some tips for successfully navigating Phase 3 so you can make it to the goal, which is Phase 4, reinvention. In that phase, you find a new purpose and meaning, and you create a new identity.
1. Make a mindset shift. The way out of being stuck isn’t distraction, it’s reinvention! You have to actively create your next chapter. Many stuck retirees try to solve a purpose problem with a busyness solution: back-to-back trips, packed calendars, and saying yes to everything. It doesn’t work. It just masks the underlying issue.
As Celia Dodd writes in her book *Not Fade Away; How to Thrive in Retirement*,
“Being busy is not to be confused with feeling fulfilled… A hectic schedule can be a distraction from exploring new opportunities that might be more satisfying.”
2. Create a curiosity list. Make a list of things you’re curious about. Not a bucket list of goals but a list of things you’ve simply wondered about. Forget practical, forget productive.
What have you always been curious about, or what are you curious about now? Then pick one thing and explore it. That often leads to number three, tiny experiments.
3. Run Tiny Experiments. Make a simple pact with yourself: “for X days I will do Y.”
For example, if you’re thinking about the possibility of volunteering at your local library, you could make a tiny experiment out of it. You could say, “For the next two months, I’ll volunteer at the library for four hours a week.” At the end, you evaluate: do I want to continue, modify, or stop this experiment?
The nice thing about tiny experiments is that you cannot fail. If it’s not for you, that’s useful information. If it works, you found a thread worth pulling.
4. Don’t commit too early while you’re exploring. Avoid major commitments. You’re testing, not signing up forever.
For example, for about six months, I volunteered at the Minuteman Missile National Historic Site, which was about an hour and a half from my home. I enjoyed the work, and it wasn’t too taxing or stressful because I only did it about once a month.
However, an opportunity arose, and I was hired to work as a part-time ranger for two days a week. Over time, I found that being very social while I’m an introvert, and the substantial travel time, were simply exhausting. I got to where I started dreading going, making the drive, and spending all day at the visitor center, and then making the drive back home. What I should have done was try that for a few weeks as a volunteer to see how it worked, then make a decision about a bigger commitment.
5. Make a money mindset shift. As you start experimenting and exploring, don’t let a scarcity mindset around money hold you back.
Time and physical capacity are your real constraints now, not dollars. We’ve spent decades saving money, but now time, not money, is the most precious resource.
In retirement, the scarce resource shifts to time and physical capacity, not dollars, assuming we’ve done a good job saving for retirement. The “go-go years” (60s), “slow-go years” (70s), and “no-go years” (80s) framework is a cornerstone of retirement planning and its message is urgent. The active window is much shorter than it looks; you need to spend more during the time you’re capable of doing more.
The Institute for Fiscal Studies found that retirees’ spending on travel and leisure peaks around age 80, then declines, not because people run out of money, but because they run out of the physical capacity to do the things that the money would buy.
What that means is, as you explore things on your curiosity list and try some tiny experiments, you need to not be afraid to spend money that’s within a reasonable budget.
The Other Side Is Real
Reinvention isn’t guaranteed, but it is possible — and the path there is more practical than most people expect.
You don’t need a dramatic epiphany or a perfect plan. You need a mindset shift, a little curiosity, and the willingness to run a few experiments without demanding they succeed.
The retirees who make it to Phase 4 aren’t the ones who had it all figured out. They’re the ones who stopped waiting to feel ready and started doing small things to find out what fits.
If you’re somewhere in Phase 2 or early Phase 3 right now, that’s not a sign you failed at retirement. It’s a sign you’re human — and that the best part may still be ahead.
Note: I wrote this blog post myself using my own words and thoughts for the initial draft. I used AI only to suggest headlines, section headings, images and text improvements.
Links to product pages on Amazon include a referral code which pays me a small percentage of the sale when products are purchased. This helps to defray some of the costs of running this site. I strive to only include links to products I believe are worth purchasing.